Ok, not sure if this will ruffle some madras feathers, but humor me...
I spent about half my life in the Northeast (college and post) around the communities and subcultures that gave rise to this fashion. I'm just going to say it: they're douches. They're generally awful people. And not just the young ones either. The parents can be as bad as the cliches.
I've never understood why the style they espouse is one people aspire to. Shallow people I can see, but in my experience in vintage menswear, collectors are much warmer, more aware of history and their surroundings, and all around decent than your average folk. So it's a huge confusion point for me.
(Even in the 80s, it was almost always the a-hole in the movies who wore this style.)
When I went to school it was practically a linear relationship- the more nantucket red and boat shoes and club ties, the more arrogant, cold, callous, unpleasant/drunk, misogynistic, downright sociopathic, etc. Coming from a much warmer environment (emotionally-speaking), to me this whole community and their behavior were pretty abhorrent, and certainly nothing to aspire to.
Even the arguable patron saint of the style, ol' JFK himself, was ethically a piece of s^%$.
So I don't get it. To me this all seems like decent, informed, insightful people chasing just the opposite.
What's the appeal?
I spent about half my life in the Northeast (college and post) around the communities and subcultures that gave rise to this fashion. I'm just going to say it: they're douches. They're generally awful people. And not just the young ones either. The parents can be as bad as the cliches.
I've never understood why the style they espouse is one people aspire to. Shallow people I can see, but in my experience in vintage menswear, collectors are much warmer, more aware of history and their surroundings, and all around decent than your average folk. So it's a huge confusion point for me.
(Even in the 80s, it was almost always the a-hole in the movies who wore this style.)
When I went to school it was practically a linear relationship- the more nantucket red and boat shoes and club ties, the more arrogant, cold, callous, unpleasant/drunk, misogynistic, downright sociopathic, etc. Coming from a much warmer environment (emotionally-speaking), to me this whole community and their behavior were pretty abhorrent, and certainly nothing to aspire to.
Even the arguable patron saint of the style, ol' JFK himself, was ethically a piece of s^%$.
So I don't get it. To me this all seems like decent, informed, insightful people chasing just the opposite.
What's the appeal?