Men's Clothing Forums banner

Spier Mackay sizing advice

14K views 5 replies 2 participants last post by  Troones  
#1 ·
I am a noob here and measure 5 foot 9.5 and average build. What you see here is a
1. 38S sport coat from S&M
2. An older 38R from polo ralph lauren

Its clear that the S&M coat is too tight but I am not sure if I need to order 38 Contemporary or 40 Slim. One thing that did worry me is that the sleeves on the S&M are already long and my shirt isn't showing (the shirt is 14.5, 33 from Charles Tyrwhitt). The sleeves on the Polo coat are shorter but the coat itself is baggy (from the back that is). The back of the coat with with the wrinkles is with buttons closed.

I tend to think 38 Contemporary is what I need but not sure. Any advice highly appreciated!
 

Attachments

#2 ·
If what you’re currently wearing is a 38 slim then 38 contemporary should work. Keep in mind that their jackets can also be let out up to 1 inch (if I remember correctly.).

I have a small collection of sport coats and blazers from S&M now. I wear their 44R contemporary whereas most other brands I’m a 42. It works for me as I have broad shoulders anyway and their natural shoulder construction helps a lot. Nice jacket!
 
#4 ·
I think the length is fine, though I tend to prefer a more traditional length anyway. You would do fine in S if your preference is for the more common shorter jackets. I’m roughly your height and wear R. So if this is a 38R slim I would try a 38R contemporary. The sleeves pretty much always have to be shortened anyway so don’t worry about sleeve length.

The contemporary is a little less nipped at the waist which should solve the problem of bunching at the back. I’m not an expert of course, but since I’m very familiar with this particular brand I feel fairly confident in offering advice.
 
#5 ·
Thanks again Troones and looks like you are from Canada as well. Here are some more pics. So 38 Contemporary as opposed to 40 Slim? They are just giving me one shot of free exchange tbh :) Yes I noticed that back bunching as well.
 

Attachments