Men's Clothing Forums banner

New Meermin Boots

7.3K views 19 replies 8 participants last post by  eagle2250  
#1 · (Edited)
Just received my second set of Meermin's.
Antique Oak shearling-lined cap-toe boots.

Image


First shot is them in ambient overhead light,
Second is with the flash on:

Image


Frankly, fortunately they look a lot more like the former to me.

I normally wear a size 12. Haven't measured myself on a Brannock device since my feet stopped growing (some 30 years ago...) On advice gleaned here and elsewhere, ordered these Hiro-lasted jumpers in UK 11. 5. Fit like a glove! A little wiggle room at the toe, tight through the instep and arch, a little heel wiggle in the right boot. (None discernible in the left. But my left foot is ~ 1/4 to 1/2 size larger than my right.) Natural bend coincides very nicely with the ball of my foot, but the arches are just slightly rearward of my natural ones. Still closer than my year-old size 12 5th Ave's.

So, I did about 30 jumping jacks, ran 1/2 mile, and walked 2 miles in them upon receipt. Then I put my heaviest wool socks on some slightly-undersize CBT's and stuffed 'em in there for the night. I'll wear 'em all day tomorrow or the next day to get them well and truly broken in. Though it's about 50 locally in the evening, and I got stuck running an hour more errands than I had bargained for, my feet didn't get overly warm. And felt no hot spots or discomfort. It's supposed to start cooling down, and I'm being sent to the Midwest in early February where highs are supposed to hover around freezing. So, they'll be getting some use coming up.

I think the leather is a gorgeous medium brown, and though I never picked up such a belt, I have 3 different ones which are only off a shade which I can pair with 'em depending on the outfit and mood: Dress brown for suits, separates, or dark chinos; tan for smart jeans or light chinos; well-worn light brown for worn-in jeans. Perfect.

In addition to being a lovely color, the leather is quite a bit more supple than the Vintage Tobacco on my size 11 wholecuts on the Elton last. Even with about 10 (walking) miles in them (no jumping jacks) those have yet to conform to my high insteps, and the laces just don't pull closed the way I would like, and expect. Perhaps when I find the right slacks to complement them, and the weather warms up a tad, I'll get to breaking those in in earnest. But I digress.

Upon initial inspection, I detected no flaws whatsoever. But I'm no expert, and was anxious to get them on my feet. At the end of the night, I could see whoever did the welt may have been learning the process. And the cutline on each boot does not align perfectly, and is not dyed on the mating faces. They are also not perfectly symmetrical from boot to boot: one is just above the forward edge of the heel; the other is about an inch forward of there. Fortunately, both are on the inner side of the shoe, where anyone not inspecting will a fine-toothed comb will be hard-pressed to see it. I also noticed 2 scuffs on the toes which I know I put there, and a couple on the heels and shaft which were probably me, but I didn't look close enough at first to see.
At the price point and expected use, I'd give them full points for fit and finish, your mileage (and pickiness) may vary.

Some have mentioned the stiffness of Meermin's studded rubber sole. I have no experience with real Dainite, but I find the Meermin version a bit more supple, grippy and communicative than the Thursday Boots version. Which, until last night, was plenty good enough for me. (Wearing suede Scouts right now.) My 2 cents.

Anyway, even though it's the most I've ever spent on footwear (other than, maybe, ski boots) I LOVE the new boots, and thank you guys for directing me to Meermin.
 
#19 ·
Glad they fit well. They look great and appear to be a good fit. You’ve gotten away with the Otterwax once, I’d be judicious in future use, as it will continue to darken the boots if used more frequently than its worn off.

The welt irregularity is an acceptable deviation in boots at that price range, better than expected at the pricing of AE, and not to be expected from Meermin as usual in future purchases, but can happen.

If you try Elton, in shoes the sizing should be the same, but boots may need a half size increase depending on how tight or loose you like. Due to the nature of the shaft holding in the foot, boots can be a little larger than shoes and fit well IMO.
 
#17 ·
I corrected the size in my original post. Hiro last runs small. I ordered these is UK 11.5. Still fit like a glove!

Third wear - arches and heels have comformed to my feet. They really feel great.

As for my oil/polish/darkening event - they are no longer a shade lighter then the accessories:

Image


But I think they are beautiful, and should get a really nice patina with age.
(California) Casual Friday:
Image
 
#16 ·
In last night's torrential downpour, the leather darkened considerably. Lightened back up as it dried, of course.
On the advice of Schott Leather, I rubbed Otterwax oil into my 40 year old A2 bomber. Feels supple, but look hardly changed.
Against the advice of Meermin, I rubbed the oil into my new boots.
A little medium brown came off onto my polishing cloth (did not happen with the jacket.)
Boots are much darker now - akin to G.H. Bass' "seahorse". It's a gorgeous hue - my seahorse Weejuns might just be my most complimented shoe ever - but it's not what these were.
I'm going to let 'em rest/cure/dry another day, then rub 'em down with AE's Walnut cream tonight. Depending on success / opinion, you may get more photos later.
 
#6 ·
Ive been wanting some meermins for awhile now but the thought of guessing my size and last scares me. I hate dealing with returns and fees. Glad to know that sizing a half size down for the Hiro is the way to go. Did you order these online and if so who helped you out with the sizing to ensure a proper fit? (or did you do your own research based on online reviews)
 
#2 ·
A handsome pair of boots, for sure. May you long wear them and may you do so only in good health! I once had a couple pair of shearling lined house shoes/bedroom slippers that were a true comfort on the foot and indeed a minor luxury that enhanced my life experience while living in Hoosierville, with it's cold, wet winters, but were a bit too much warmth on the foot to seem useful, after we relocated to central Florida. :(