Men's Clothing Forums banner

Allen-Edmonds Sizing Question

14K views 5 replies 4 participants last post by  AscotWithShortSleeves  
#1 ·
Evening, gents. Looking for a little advice from the AE experts here: I'm thinking about getting a pair of Dalton boots but am vexed as to what size to get--9.5D or 10D. I know they're on the 511 last, which is based on the 7 last. (I don't have a store near me, but I prefer shopping online anyway.)

I usually wear a 10D in AE shoes, especially on the 65 last. I have high arches and a fairly narrow heel, compared with the ball of my foot. (The other shoe barely has enough room.)

My 10D Lexingtons are super comfortable but do have just the slightest bit of extra room in the heel and forefoot--but I never notice it unless I think about it. My Burtons are also 10D, as are a pair of four-eye laceups whose model name I've forgotten. (They're sitting at work, so I can't check.) The only 10D shoes I own that are too big are the Aberdeens, and I know they're an outlier. (I installed some felt tongue and heel pads and wear heavier socks with them.)

My Park Avenues are size 9.5D (also on the 65 last), and one shoe is slightly too snug near the ball of the foot.

If the 9.5D is on the snug side, and the 7 last is slightly roomier from ball to heel than the 5 last, then does that mean I'm better off getting 9.5D in the Daltons, since they would have extra width built in?

Thanks for any suggestions or thoughts.
 
Discussion starter · #6 ·
I find the 65 last extremely narrow in the forefoot. I have Strands and park Aves in 8.5eee, but all my other AEs are 9e. I have even gone to a 9d in one of the wider lasts, I believe it's the Gobi chukka on the (possibly discontinued) 809 last.

My only 511 last is a pair of long branch in 9e. They fit fairly well, but I probably could have gone down to the d width. They're not too roomy normally because I wear them with thick socks, but they're certainly not snug up front.
Thank you! This is very helpful. This tells me the 511 really is quite roomy vs the 65.

Given how massive the global shoe market is, it's amazing there isn't more size standardization. I'm a 10D in most AE and in my New Balance running shoes, 9.5 in my Alico hiking boots, and my uber-comfy Italian-made 15-year-old Hugo Boss laceups are marked size 9.