smr:
You might be right about the Brooksease jacket. I only took a quick look at it and I think there are forum members who know definitely, so I'll defer to their authority. If I screwed this one up, I apologize.
I might be a little behind on Brooks' pricing, especially since I usually only shop at sale time. My understanding is that Brooksease are about $600 retail/ $400 sale, 1818 are about $800 retail / $500 sale, and GFS are about $1200 retail / $800 sale.
Am I approximately correct?
I have two Brooks GFs, both purchased at sale price for around $7xx. At that price I think they are great. For $1200 I think you have a few other options. I think Canali can be had for about $1400 retail and at that price they are a better deal than GF. Again this is my $.02 ...
I don't own any HFs and I haven't checked one out recently. My general impression is that they were somewhere between 1818 and GF in quality and I think they start at about $1100 ... not a particulary good deal.
As for the 1818 line, I think I'm being a bit of a snob. They're probably fine suits. I just prefer the GF and at the sale prices, the extra $300 dollars is defintely worth it.