I did not intend to start an Adirondack version of Hatfield and McCoys. Being in the Trad forum, I argued for wood over plastic. Can a use case be made for plastic (next you'll offer me your story Board, but I digress), yes. Hickory is traditional as is cedar, pine is often used now, resulting in some of the dissapointing results noted above. As it is with many things in life, functionality and longevity are a function of the quality of materials, finish and craftsmanship.
View attachment 28403
One room in my bungalow, still a work in progress.