Hinton and Hinton, like most shops on the square, is simply done well. It's a neat shop with a great atmosphere. The service was surprisingly friendly, I've been in there before when it was a little cold. They had some great products but you're correct it is a 180 from Landry's. Consider the prominence of stylish XMI shirts - they were a real turnoff.
While Distinctive may have a bias point of view, I have an outsider's perspective, and I agree Oxford can be snooty. It's a great town and really enjoy the dynamic of the small town feel combined with great shopping, but I don't understand the air of superiority. But I hail from South Carolina and we can have the same attitude about our state.