Men's Clothing Forums banner
1 - 12 of 12 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
1,103 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Recently my love for longwings was reawakened. I have been a longtime AE customer, but as has been documented many times on the boards here, I've seen some not-so-great QC come out of there recently. I wanted a new pair (ie not from dabondo on ebay, not like-new ebay, etc) and wanted something a little different from the typical colors.

I've also read the negative opinions of Florsheim on here. Over the years they've had several things that looked interesting (I still kick myself for not getting a pair of white Veblen longwings when they were out), but I always stayed away because of the image I had of them from comments on this and other sites.

When I started to search for longwings that were a little different, I googled something (don't remember what) and wound up on Florsheim's site, looking at their Heritage model. The color I liked was Sandstone, which looks like a natural color:

Footwear Brown Shoe Outdoor shoe Sneakers

I found a 20% code online for Florsheim, which made these $144. (Code: LNKFLLC8)
It took about eight business days to get them. Here is the presentation when they arrived:
Brown Publication Wood Audio equipment Gadget


Shoe bags were included, although they're pretty flimsy, and I don't use shoe bags anyway. Still, a nice touch, given that AE is ditching shoe bags.

Brown Product Sleeve Rectangle Wood


The shoes are finished very nicely, and a careful examination revealed no flaws in the leather or problems with construction or finish. This picture is not representative of the color, the photo on their web site is accurate.
Footwear Brown Shoe Wood Walking shoe


Close-up on the brogueing on the toes:
Footwear Shoe Walking shoe Font Human leg
Footwear Brown Shoe Leg Human body

Tagged as Horween leather. Whether a retro attempt or not, it's a nice touch.
Brown Product Gold Font Eyewear

The shoes are listed as "a flexible leather sole with a Goodyear welt construction" on the website. The soles have a coating on them, like lacquer or shellac, perhaps to allow them to use cheaper leather? Never seen that on a leather-soled shoe before.
Footwear Brown Shoe Product Musical instrument accessory
Brown Shoe Amber Wood Material property

Heels appear to be hand-nailed, not sure you'd make a machine do the nailing so unevenly. Heels are solid without being rock-hard like the old J&M heels were.
Outerwear Sleeve Wood Waist Dress
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,103 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
Overall I am very happy with these shoes. They appear to be built very well and I expect them to last a long time. I own 14 pairs of Allen Edmonds and I think these are as well-made as any of them. They are made in India like the Kenmoors, so if you want made in USA, these are not for you.

I am looking forward to wearing these with jeans or khakis; my wife and a colleague agree I can't do these with a suit.

If you want a very nice longwing, I recommend these. I like them so much I am going to try one of the other colors. I know the other colors are not Horween leather, but they offer free returns, so I'll give them a shot.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
662 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
13,646 Posts
Nice looking shoes and thank you for all the details and observations.

I agree with your wife and colleague re wearing them with a suit with the exception (every rule has one they say) being some summer suits - an off-white linen, maybe a seersucker or a tan-ish silk - might look quite sharp with those shoes.

I'm thinking of them as a replacement for tan summer suede dress shoe with those suits. Just a thought as it might be a nice and different look.

Enjoy your new shoes - they look great.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,103 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
Thanks for all the kind words. I have since added another Heritage, and a burgundy pair of Kenmoor 2s. Very pleased with both pairs, and would buy more of Florsheim's Goodyear welted shoes in the future.

Heritage:
Footwear Brown Shoe Sneakers Walking shoe

Burgundy:
Brown Outdoor shoe Walking shoe Magenta Athletic shoe
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,103 Posts
Discussion Starter · #10 ·
I'm thinking of them as a replacement for tan summer suede dress shoe with those suits. Just a thought as it might be a nice and different look.

Enjoy your new shoes - they look great.
I'm definitely getting a summer suit made in February or March this year, and I will give them a go with that suit. I agree, that sounds like a nice match!
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top