Men's Clothing Forums banner

Purchasing Experience with Cheaney Shoes

5439 Views 20 Replies 10 Participants Last post by  Flanderian
This is about a recent ordering experience with the shoemaker Joseph Cheaney & Sons. I was considering another pair of loafers and realized I was so well pleased with the fit and comfort, as well as the quality, of a pair of Cheaney Howard R model loafers that I had purchased last summer from Herring that I should see if there were any others on the same last. The marvelous service at Herring was consulted first, but they had no other loafers on the 5203 last. So I went directly to the Cheaney website and was offered a number of choices on the 5203 last, including some sale items that don't appear on their normal pages. (I believe the site read my URL as new and threw me a bone.)

Among the choices was a brown smooth calf with rubber sole version of their still offered for sale Hudson model with leather sole. As the sizes were limited for all sale items I looked at, I suspect this version was discontinued. But as it was precisely what I was looking for, particularly the rubber sole that I prefer for most casual footwear, I couldn't care less if it was discontinued, and with a 100 Pound Sterling discount it was a no-brainer for me.

But now it gets interesting: I ordered it on-line very late Wednesday night. Actually, it was technically Thursday morning, as it was after 12AM. On Friday the following day the nice man from DHL Express delivered them at 3:30PM to my front door. That's extraordinarily fine customer service. It's remarkable that I could order a pair of shoes from England, and receive them the next day! Herring is the only other European source with which I've had experience that can be that fast.

When the shoes arrived, they were exactly what I hoped for in terms of appearance and quality of build. I could say I'm becoming a fan of Cheaney footwear, but I think I already was.

The only drama in the transaction was not Cheaney's fault, but rather my card company's, Capital One. Cheaney evidently uses a 3rd party site to process bank cards. Capital One declined it twice, and then I called them, and they had flagged it as potentially fraudulent. They approved the transaction and lifted the restriction when I assured them it was legitimate. Had the same experience with Pediwear a couple years ago, who also uses a 3rd party to clear bank cards. Wish Capital One could get its act together. These are both solid businesses, and there's nothing in the history of the use of my card to suggest it should be a problem for Capital One.
See less See more
21 - 21 of 21 Posts
I think you were one of the posters that turned me to try Cheaney. Man do I love my Cheaney shoes. Wearing my Jackie III as I type!!
If you like the mahogany grain hide as well as I do, you likely know that Cheaney makes a blucher/derby also with a Dainite sole on the same last, the 125. I know Eagle has this shoe and regards it well. And I have the Howard R penny, also with a Dainite sole in the same hide two. It's on their 5203 last, which is a more traditional round toe last that's a little fuller than 125, but they both fit me very well and are very comfortable. Rarely would I boy two shoes in a hide so distinctive, but I made an exception, as I'm that fond of it.

Cheaney shoes are insanely comfortable on my feet. Sadly, I only have 3 - the Manchester, a very nice side gusset slip on that I wish they still made and 2 Brooks English numbers from back in the day. The BE ones are without a doubt the most comfortable oxford shoes I have ever owned. I still like C&J, but Cheaneys are more comfortable on my feet.
Thank you! It's helpful to have the broader experience added to what I've learned, which tends to support my hypothesis, that Cheaney shoes seem to offer comfort to many wearers.
21 - 21 of 21 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.