He's got quite a healthy point, Boggie. I may not be the most experienced or knowledgeable person about clothes, but I think I'm correct in agreeing with him. And I'm sure I'm not the only one who says that if the forum were full of people who think the same way as you, Ask Andy would not be the most popular clothing forum. It would, in fact, be quite alienating. I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish by driving off TMW shoppers "for the good of the forum" and creating completely inflexible rules that follow only your aesthetics. I may not be the best dressed here either, but I've gone a long way in three years and I'm still learning. I've fortunately learned to disregard the really black and white opinions of you and other members like you that I've seen here.
Please don't think this is an ad hominem attack, I am merely pointing out what I've seen. I have gotten frustrated a couple of times with you and other members with similar advice though, I'll admit.
I'll tell you what. I may be going on a road trip later this year up north. If I can find time to stop over for a bit in Cambridge, we should sit down and have a drink. I have a feeling you're actually a really decent chap in person. I'm also eager to see how you dress and what works well for you that you have these strict rules from which to follow (which may be why you're very adamant about telling these to others and think they are absolutely correct, and I think that is understandable to a degree). To date, I don't think I have seen a single picture of you on this forum so if you could provide one for me to recognise you, that would also help. Please, let me know if you're interested.