[Zinc2005]

Hello,

I am trying to improve a modest tie collection. I don't want to own more than 10 ties and would prefer to own even fewer. I have one charcoal suit, and one nice navy jacket that I wear with odd trousers. I don't have much occasion to dress up. I work in a business where I communicate with my clients primarily through phone and email. I do meet with each client in person at least once a year and when I do I want to look sharp. I'm in my early 30s if that makes a difference. Could you all offer some suggestions about what I might want to add/remove from my current lineup? Does anything jump out as looking cheesy/dated that I should be eliminating? Is there something missing that I would obviously benefit from owning?

Most of these ties are of reasonable quality. I would say Brooks bros makers quality level. The last champagne looking tie is a Zenga and is noticeably better quality than the rest.

Thanks


What I have after pairing down some lower quality/less worn stranglers

This reads as navy. Not sure if this is a tie trying to appear to be a grenadine or if this is an acceptable pattern in it's own right? I have only recently been made aware of grenadines and so the thought that the tie was trying to potentially imitate one is a new concept


Same concern here.. is this trying to look like a grenadine?

This is not as bright as the picture would have you believe

This reads as burgandy

 

[drlivingston]

No tie collection is complete without solid navy and solid burgundy grenadines. Their versatility is unmatched.

 

[Zinc2005]

No tie collection is complete without solid navy and solid burgundy grenadines. Their versatility is unmatched.

Would you suggest replacing Tie #1 and Tie #4 with grenadines then?

 

[Flanderian]

No tie collection is complete without solid navy and solid burgundy grenadines. Their versatility is unmatched.

+1!

Hello,

I am trying to improve a modest tie collection. I don't want to own more than 10 ties and would prefer to own even fewer. I have one charcoal suit, and one nice navy jacket that I wear with odd trousers. I don't have much occasion to dress up. I work in a business where I communicate with my clients primarily through phone and email. I do meet with each client in person at least once a year and when I do I want to look sharp. I'm in my early 30s if that makes a difference. Could you all offer some suggestions about what I might want to add/remove from my current lineup? Does anything jump out as looking cheesy/dated that I should be eliminating? Is there something missing that I would obviously benefit from owning?

Most of these ties are of reasonable quality. I would say Brooks bros makers quality level. The last champagne looking tie is a Zenga and is noticeably better quality than the rest.

Thanks


What I have after pairing down some lower quality/less worn stranglers

This reads as navy. Not sure if this is a tie trying to appear to be a grenadine or if this is an acceptable pattern in it's own right? I have only recently been made aware of grenadines and so the thought that the tie was trying to potentially imitate one is a new concept


Same concern here.. is this trying to look like a grenadine?

This is not as bright as the picture would have you believe

This reads as burgandy

But while I'll offer a few thoughts, I think the 6 ties you already have are handsome and very suitable for your stated purpose.

During my 40 years in business, I was a tie-aholic! And over that time purchased and replaced several tie wardrobes. I still have about 100 , but have no interest in whether they are in, or out, of fashion as they've all become dear friends of which I'm very fond

While I would never discourage you from purchasing all your ties new (I did.) the price of quality new ties has become costly. Even a company like Sam Hober which has a comparatively excellent price to quality ratio is, none-the-less, costly.

And ties are the one article of clothing that I would not hesitate to buy used if it's a clean, handsome quality tie in good shape. IMHO, ties have 3 relevant qualities; they should look rich, hang straight and tie a good knot. Since it's only decoration, intricacy of construction isn't important to me.

In addition to the above mentioned solids, a couple patterns might be both useful and enjoyable. Though exercise prudence, as the road to hell, or at least to an empty wallet can be paved with such enthusiasms. I love paisleys, and there are many classics among them, but they are just slightly more flamboyant, so you may wish to consider a couple striped ties as your patterns. A few I grabbed from the Sam Hober site I would like that I think might suit your wardrobe and stated uses -

 

[drlivingston]

Paging @paul winston

 

[SG_67]

Fewer ties? Are you mad?

 

[Dhaller]

Not to miss the essential point - and I admire minimalism - but I wouldn't worry too much about "too many ties"; I never heard of someone having a tie-storage problem.

Ties are one of the few bits of fun men are permitted to have, clothingwise - why box yourself in?

DH

 

[Zinc2005]

Not to miss the essential point - and I admire minimalism - but I wouldn't worry too much about "too many ties"; I never heard of someone having a tie-storage problem.

Ties are one of the few bits of fun men are permitted to have, clothingwise - why box yourself in?

DH

I understand your point. For me, my mind is clearest when I have several great options, compared with many potentially lukewarm options.

 

[SG_67]

I understand your point. For me, my mind is clearest when I have several great options, compared with many potentially lukewarm options.

There's really nothing contradictory in wanting many great options.

Ties are a nice guilty pleasure. As Dhaller states, they take up very little space and are a nice, fun way to add some interest to an otherwise conservative ensemble. You're already restricting your suit options, have a little fun here.

Just my two cents.

 

[never behind]

No tie collection is complete without solid navy and solid burgundy grenadines. Their versatility is unmatched.

Agreed! I am a tie minimalist simply because my work rarely calls for it and I dislike wearing ties. After consulting the board a year ago I purchased a navy and wine grenadine tie. I also bought a red ancient madder (below). After browsing several vendors recommended, I went with Chipp Neckwear based on quality and price (plus Mr Winston is a great AAAC member). I've been very pleased. Excellent ties!

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Zinc2005]

Thanks All! Especially 'Flanderian' for the very detailed response. Are those essentially Brooks Bros repp patterns made by hober? I know I recognize the #1 striped pattern but not sure on the rest. Since everyone is suggesting grenadines as musts, and Chipp has been highly recommended by many, perhaps I will start with that. Thanks 'Never Behind' for sharing your praises about Chipp and suggesting that beautiful madder for consideration.

Since I have never owned a grenadine I am hesitant to buy a color I already have covered until I know I really enjoy it.

Forest green Chipp Grenadine?
https://www.chippneckwear.com/forest-grenadine-tie/

That, the rust, or muted purple could add something new to the mix.

 

[Flanderian]

Thanks All! Especially 'Flanderian' for the very detailed response. Are those essentially Brooks Bros repp patterns made by hober? I know I recognize the #1 striped pattern but not sure on the rest. Since everyone is suggesting grenadines as musts, and Chipp has been highly recommended by many, perhaps I will start with that. Thanks 'Never Behind' for sharing your praises about Chipp and suggesting that beautiful madder for consideration.

Since I have never owned a grenadine I am hesitant to buy a color I already have covered until I know I really enjoy it.

Forest green Chipp Grenadine?
https://www.chippneckwear.com/forest-grenadine-tie/

That, the rust, or muted purple could add something new to the mix.

You're very welcome! :beer:

I don't know that Brooks has any striped patterns that are unique, so I would tend to suspect that the Hober ties are simply classic patterns that have been sold by many different sources.

While the term "rep" is often used to indicate a type of striped tie, it actually describes how the silk is woven, though often with striped patterns. Rep indicates a type of twill with the regular repeating pattern of hills and valleys typical of twill weaves.

 

[winghus]

Grenadines are somewhat fragile but if that doesn't bother you go to town. I have the rust Chipp grenadine and the color is great with a navy blazer or dark blue patterned jacket of any type. I don't particularly like that beige tie on the far right and would drop it. If I had to pair down to 10 and your two colors of jacket, the absolute musts IMO are:

Navy solid with some texture (grenadine would go here)
Burgundy solid with some texture (same as above)
Rust solid or patterned
Muted orange pattern
Grey lighter than your charcoal suit but not super light, more mid-grey

The other 4 your personal choice but coordinating with the two jackets. For the suit I would add:
Navy or blue neat (a small tight pattern of regular dots or shapes)
Burgundy pindot or neat
Forest green neat

For the blazer I would add:
Brown from chocolate to mid-brown but not a light color like beige
A Repp stripe of your choice or
A madder in your color of choice
Wool challis ties are really nice but you seldom see them in the cheaper brands.

If you wear patterned shirts a lot, maybe more solids than patterns for the ties. I personally seldom wear a patterned shirt and patterned tie together and also tend not to wear more than two patterns between jacket, tie, shirt, and square. I've seldom seen four patterns look harmonious and even with three it can be difficult with a limited set of ties.

Look at the navy jacket combos here for some inspiration:
https://www.styleforum.net/threads/...ation-and-more-hd-directors-cut-redux.429429/

 

[Adriel Rowley]

Thanks All! Especially 'Flanderian' for the very detailed response. Are those essentially Brooks Bros repp patterns made by hober? I know I recognize the #1 striped pattern but not sure on the rest. Since everyone is suggesting grenadines as musts, and Chipp has been highly recommended by many, perhaps I will start with that. Thanks 'Never Behind' for sharing your praises about Chipp and suggesting that beautiful madder for consideration.

Since I have never owned a grenadine I am hesitant to buy a color I already have covered until I know I really enjoy it.

Forest green Chipp Grenadine?
https://www.chippneckwear.com/forest-grenadine-tie/

That, the rust, or muted purple could add something new to the mix.

My suggestion is to consider your favorite color(s) are and what shirts be worn with the tie. For example, if most your shirts are blue, a rust be the opposite and be high contrast. If mostly whites, a rust I think looks better on warm tones.

Hopes this helps.

 

[Barrister & Solicitor]

You've received very good advice thus far.

I would emphasize that you should visit a few thrift stores and purchase inexpensive ties.

Why "a few thrift stores"? I've found that some stores end up with better stock than others.

Also, keep in mind that if you find luxury brand ones, you may even be able to sell them on eBay if you get tired of them after a while.