[rhz]

It's been frustrating trying to find AE shoes that fit. Depending on the shoe, I can be anywhere from 8.5 to 9.5 (I'm 9.5B on the Brannock). There are many good deals on ebay for older models. Unfortunately, it is difficult to find sizing information for such shoes (unlike the current models, which often have good crowd-sourced, review-based sizing info on the AE website).

I know that my situation is not unique, but I'm curious: were AE sizing conventions more standard in the past or were they alway highly shoe-dependent?

Thanks.

 

[SG_67]

The difference can be explained by the last the shoe is made on. Shoe size is but one indicator of fit. Much like the Brannock device. It’s meant to give you a starting point.

My advise is try on several pair in store. Get an idea of what fits and what doesn’t.

 

[FLMike]

I wear 9.5D in every AE model I’ve ever owned. And it’s been several...loafers, balmorals, bluchers, chukkas.

 

[FLMike]

My advise is try on several pair in store. Get an idea of what fits and what doesn't.

I always thought you were American for some reason.

 

[SG_67]

I always thought you were American for some reason.

You caught me.

 

[SG_67]

I wear 9.5D in every AE model I've ever owned. And it's been several...loafers, balmorals, bluchers, chukkas.

9.5D is my size as well. But my feet are not all that fussy.

I can appreciate those with feet that are and who may have difficulty finding shoes that fit.