Men's Clothing Forums banner
1 - 8 of 8 Posts

· Premium Member
Joined
·
27,866 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
My recent purchase from Herring included a small booklet extolling their footwear. Entirely appropriate IMHO, and it also included some detailed generic recommendations for care. Here they are, along with my personal experience where I feel relevant.

- New shoes should initially be worn for no more than two or three hours at a time.

I agree.

- Only when your shoes and feet have become accustomed to each other should they be worn for a whole day.

Agreed.

- Try to wear your shoes in dry conditions for the first few occasions. Avoid getting your shoes extremely wet. Should this occur, allow your shoes to dry naturally on shoe trees and lay the shoes on their sides rather than on their soles. Never use direct heat to speed up the drying process.

Knew some of that, but not wearing them in wet conditions is new information in which I can see the wisdom.

- Always use a shoehorn when putting on your shoes, whether they are slip-ons, buckled or lace-ups. Otherwise the back of the shoe will be weakened.

Absolutely!

- Do not wear the same shoes on two consecutive days. The leather needs time to dry and recover after each wear.

Yes, I find at least 3 days between wearings optimal.

- Shoe trees should be used after each wear to maintain the shape of the shoe and help them to dry out.

Yes. But I've found that after being on the trees for 3 days, they can actually be removed without affecting the benefit. I do this simply to reuse them in other shoes, but there's no reason they can't remain tree'ed until the next wearing if that's what you prefer.

- You can wipe your shoes down and apply a quality cream or wax polish after every wear to feed the leather and prevent cracking, even if the shoes do not appear to have lost any of their original shine.

This is conventional British and American advice, but the one thing with which I strongly disagree. I typically only use shoe cream, and that infrequently. I have shoes over 30 years old, and they're not dried out, and not cracked. Conversely, I once used wax after each wearing, and this truly did seem to dry out the leather, so that after a few years, they looked as if they might be 30 years old!

- Avoid unsuitable additions to either sole or heel, such as stick on soles. These can affect the balance, comfort and life of your shoes and may void any manufacturer's warranty.

I have no experience with this, but I know some here have done so, and feel it's very beneficial. Not to dispute that, but I sense there may be a kernel of wisdom in this recommendation.

- Repair your shoes in good time by using a reputable cobbler. The majority of our shoes can also be returned to the factory for a full repair on the original last. This is the best way to gain the most from your top quality shoe.

Amen.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,357 Posts
- New shoes should initially be worn for no more than two or three hours at a time.


Is this so you don't kill your feet or is there some benefit to the shoe? I wore a new pair today and was planning on changing after a while but never did. My feet never bothered me and before I knew it, the work day was done.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

· Read Only
Joined
·
2,318 Posts
You can wipe your shoes down and apply a quality cream or wax polish after every wear to feed the leather and prevent cracking, even if the shoes do not appear to have lost any of their original shine.

Avoid unsuitable additions to either sole or heel, such as stick on soles. These can affect the balance, comfort and life of your shoes and may void any manufacturer's warranty.

Are the only ones I disagree with, every wear is a bit ridiculous. A good brushing and buffing is usually all that's needed.

Topies have been a lifesaver for me. They're quite thin, yet quite grippy. I haven't noticed any difference in balance, and they've extended the life of my soles as well.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
27,866 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 · (Edited)
- New shoes should initially be worn for no more than two or three hours at a time.


Is this so you don't kill your feet or is there some benefit to the shoe? I wore a new pair today and was planning on changing after a while but never did. My feet never bothered me and before I knew it, the work day was done.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I think that's the main reason, but that's going to differ by individual and the particular pair of footwear.

But there may be a secondary benefit; a traditionally made shoe has a lot more components that I think may be realized. And to some degree, "a lot of moving parts" as these components will experience subtle adjustment when the shoe is worn to eventually come into the best possible alignment for your foot. It may be possible that if these adjustments occur more incrementally, the final result is improved.

But that's pure conjecture.
 

· Connoisseur/Curmudgeon Emeritus - Moderator
Joined
·
37,122 Posts
You can wipe your shoes down and apply a quality cream or wax polish after every wear to feed the leather and prevent cracking, even if the shoes do not appear to have lost any of their original shine.

Avoid unsuitable additions to either sole or heel, such as stick on soles. These can affect the balance, comfort and life of your shoes and may void any manufacturer's warranty.

Are the only ones I disagree with, every wear is a bit ridiculous. A good brushing and buffing is usually all that's needed.

Topies have been a lifesaver for me. They're quite thin, yet quite grippy. I haven't noticed any difference in balance, and they've extended the life of my soles as well.
Great thread, but I agree with delicious scent's points of disagreement with the guidance offered by Herring.

PS: In the interest of full disclosure, I am a huge fan of Herring. ;)
 

· Vendor
Joined
·
36 Posts
Morning all, as usual a great post and you make some very valid points. I agree in regards to the advice the shoes should be polished daily, this is overkill and the build up of polish could actually make it look as though the leather is cracking (it would just be the polish cracking of course but still, not a great look). We have quite a lot of brochures already printed so we can't amend this until they run out, likely next year but I will ensure it is amended to advise that you should essentially just keep on top of creaming and polishing (as I am sure you all know far too well).

In regards to the advice on additions to the sole, this is purely because manufacturers void any warranty on a pair of shoes if an addition has been made to them. This is not to say a good craftsman cannot do a fantastic job but they just cannot be regulated by us or the manufacturer.

I hope this helps and makes sense, if any clarification is needed please let me know.

Have a wonderful day everyone,

Chris
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
27,866 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Morning all, as usual a great post and you make some very valid points. I agree in regards to the advice the shoes should be polished daily, this is overkill and the build up of polish could actually make it look as though the leather is cracking (it would just be the polish cracking of course but still, not a great look). We have quite a lot of brochures already printed so we can't amend this until they run out, likely next year but I will ensure it is amended to advise that you should essentially just keep on top of creaming and polishing (as I am sure you all know far too well).

In regards to the advice on additions to the sole, this is purely because manufacturers void any warranty on a pair of shoes if an addition has been made to them. This is not to say a good craftsman cannot do a fantastic job but they just cannot be regulated by us or the manufacturer.

I hope this helps and makes sense, if any clarification is needed please let me know.

Have a wonderful day everyone,

Chris
Irrespective of any exceptions, I am grateful that your firm would bother to provide such thoughtful and useful information. I find it another facet of the exemplary customer service I've enjoyed when doing business with you.

Thank you!
 
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top