[Terpoxon]

Midnight blue. It will be virtually indistinguishable from black except under artificial light, then it will look blacker than black.

 

[Terpoxon]

My brother recently ordered a suit (a Baroni from Jeff on Ebay) and it was meant to be a very dark blue. When it arrived he swore it was black. I looked at it and thought it was black as well. We put it side by side with my tux and only then could we tell for sure that it was blue. In most circumstances midnight blue will look like black. But, as most people have said, if this is the only one you'll have and you're more comfortable with black, then get black.

 

[Terpoxon]

Changed your mind, I see

If it were me, I'd get midnight blue. The board seems to be generally giving the advice for black. It doesn't really matter to me what the OP gets. Like I said, if he feels "safer" with black, he should get black. Ultimately he has to be able to wear it confidently, whether its black, blue or pink.

 

[Terpoxon]

I had a horrible experience with Jeff and Baroni and will not recommend him.

I've dealt with Jeff many times, and his customer service is excellent. He is very friendly, efficient and helpful. Many others on this site have had the same experience with him. He is very fast with his service and communication and he generally has a good policy on returns and exchanges. I'd be curious to hear about the nature of your bad experience.