[Hector Freemantle]

Samuel Windsor offer inexpensive leather shoes, though they get little appreciation on this forum. Adding a rubber sole over the leather will prolong wear. You have to be careful which models you select. Visit the shop in person is the best advice. I have tan chukka and semi brogue, which are fine IMO.

A couple of questions about the Samuel Windsor.

1) What's the lining like?
2) Are they polished leather?

I'm not able to try them out as they only deliver to the UK. But if I were in the UK, I'd definitely give them a whirl.