It's been discussed here ad nasuseam, but....

The pair of lined Alden LHSs I own, I wear in my true size (11D), but my unlined Alden Brooks LHSs are a 1/2 size down (10 1/2 D).

You could always use an online retailer that a lot of guys here use, get your true size, and if they don't fit, exchange them for a 1/2 size up or down. Do remember though, most folks won't do an exchange if the shoes have been creased. That could be an option if there isn't another brick and mortar store near you.

 

I think it is too much to ask, unless of course the store volunteers to do it. You could guide them gently.

 

I don't think it's too much to "ask", but it might be too much to expect. All you can do is let them know your concerns, ask if that's a possible solution, and see what they have to say.

Shell Aldens are expensive, and at least for the the LHS is hard to fit, so I think your concerns are valid.

 

I don't think it's too much to "ask", but it might be too much to expect. All you can do is let them know your concerns, ask if that's a possible solution, and see what they have to say.

Shell Aldens are expensive, and at least for the the LHS is hard to fit, so I think your concerns are valid.

I agree, it really depends on your particular store. If I owned it, I would certainly do all I could to please the customer.