Men's Clothing Forums banner
1 - 20 of 59 Posts

· Premium Member
Joined
·
27,866 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
There are men who like wearing fine scent, others don't. And the reasons for one are as good as those for the other. Certainly, a man needs only to be clean to be well groomed. But scent is something I've enjoyed for over 60 years and is as much a part of my personal presentation as the jacket, shoes or tie I chose.

Some men have been taught that any fine scent is offensive. Others that if the scent is detectable, it's too strong. That's unfortunate. However the basis for this may be that some scents often are offensive, and that if a wearer has elected to bathe in one, it will be overpowering. It's interesting that many, if not most, of the best scents often aren't as strong as the cheaper ones. And without delving into the various reasons for this, I find this characteristic useful, as I require any scent I wear to be worn discretely.

There are many good ways in which to choose which of our fine scents we wish to wear. I've found that different scents lend themselves better to some seasons than others. Consequently, I tend to rotate my scents by season.

Long ago I bypassed the heavily advertised scents, usually associated with international designer brands, and often advertised by depicting Vikings or Greek gods. Instead I find I typically prefer lesser known fine scents which are made by firms which mostly stick to the business of making scent.

While fine scent is an international business with the same perfumers (Noses) often designing scents for various brands, scent houses tend to have some unifying characteristics, and the nationality with which that brand is associated tends to have some similarities. You might call them types, or flavors. The three with which I'm most familiar are English, Italian and French, all with significant scent brands. They all have virtues, but long experimentation has taught me that I most often prefer the French variety of scents.

In this thread I am going to discuss some fine scents which compose my winter scent wardrobe. Characteristically, I will start with a scent which is likely to be the most challenging scent I describe, simply because it's currently the scent about which I'm most passionate.

This is Annick Goutal's Encens Flamboyant. - This scent was first offered in 2007 and was composed by perfumers Camille Goutal and Isabelle Doyen. Fine scents are often compared to musical compositions with top, middle and base scent notes as the scent evolves during wear.

Encens Flamboyant roughly translates to flaming incense. It's intended to echo frankincense and fine fir resins added to a smoldering fire. And it does! The main notes I, and many others detect are smoke and pine. The smoke hits first and can be a bit harsh, perhaps almost medicinal until it quiets down when the smell of pine begins to become more prominent. As I said, it's challenging, but for me it becomes both warm, yet somewhat mysterious as the notes play hide and seek with each other. And despite this description, this is really a subtle scent which stays close to the skin despite being EDP strength. Those used to the strong, sweet scents which are more typical of drug/department store scents that hit you over the head shouldn't waste their time with it. But those who like incense and pine, and apply this scent sparingly and dispersed, may find themselves enwrapped in a subtle winter mystery.

1577983977657.png


 

· Registered
Joined
·
722 Posts
Personally, I haven't worn cologne since trying some after Walt Frazier disclosed, in Rockin Steady - A Guide to Basketball and Cool, that he wore ?Aramis?, but my wife does enjoy the smell of a fire, and after watching that Katie Puckerik review I should probably revisit. Ha ha. That review was worth watching. I've subscribed.

Years ago, if memory serves, there were ads for scents containing pherones which were claimed to have desirable effects with the ladies. Those seemed promising.

Until Flanderian's post I had never considered scent as an element of dressing well that would need coordinating with what else is worn and the context for which the wearing is done. Very interesting, as usual.
 

· Connoisseur/Curmudgeon Emeritus - Moderator
Joined
·
37,122 Posts
I shower and wash my hair with a bar of Irish Spring Deodorant Soap which leaves me "fresh and clean as a whistle" and smelling just that way. I try to insure any colognes or aftershaves that I apply complement that 'just out of the shower' smell. Geo F. Trumpers Essence of Lime cologne is effective in achieving that end. I also occasionally apply one of Geo F. Trumpers scents that leaves one smelling faintly like violets. Pretty prissy, huh? LOL. ;)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
7,064 Posts
I have a wardrobe of scents, rather in the same way that I have a wardrobe of everything else - a sense of curiosity, a long life, and a hyperactive credit card.

My first husband also left behind a large collection of scents, some of which he acquired in a mania of purchases, only for him to abandon interest in them, and revert to his standby - Hermes Eau de l'Orange Vert, which he would buy, when he found it at a good price, in mass quantities.

I have been working through his older scents, wearing them on the weekends or as the weather permits (the heaviest scents - Penhaligon's LP9, and Patou for Men - get worn only when the temperatures go below freezing). He was also given, some 35+ years ago, a bottle of Bernard Lalande, which he never liked, and I always did, which I use only for special occasions (the last wearing was for the Frick Autumn Dinner).

For my own tastes, I use scents from three English-based perfumers - Trumpers (Skye), Floris (Elite in cooler months, Cefiro in warmer months) and Penhaligon's (Hamman Bouquet, which I'm wearing today; Eau Sans Pareil; Esprit de Roi; Racquets, occasionally, as it's been discontinued; and the aforementioned LP9, which, after it's gone, I will not replace).
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,785 Posts
There are men who like wearing fine scent, others don't. And the reasons for one are as good as those for the other. Certainly, a man needs only to be clean to be well groomed. But scent is something I've enjoyed for over 60 years and is as much a part of my personal presentation as the jacket, shoes or tie I chose.

Some men have been taught that any fine scent is offensive. Others that if the scent is detectable, it's too strong. That's unfortunate. However the basis for this may be that some scents often are offensive, and that if a wearer has elected to bathe in one, it will be overpowering. It's interesting that many, if not most, of the best scents often aren't as strong as the cheaper ones. And without delving into the various reasons for this, I find this characteristic useful, as I require any scent I wear to be worn discretely.

There are many good ways in which to choose which of our fine scents we wish to wear. I've found that different scents lend themselves better to some seasons than others. Consequently, I tend to rotate my scents by season.

Long ago I bypassed the heavily advertised scents, usually associated with international designer brands, and often advertised by depicting Vikings or Greek gods. Instead I find I typically prefer lesser known fine scents which are made by firms which mostly stick to the business of making scent.

While fine scent is an international business with the same perfumers (Noses) often designing scents for various brands, scent houses tend to have some unifying characteristics, and the nationality with which that brand is associated tends to have some similarities. You might call them types, or flavors. The three with which I'm most familiar are English, Italian and French, all with significant scent brands. They all have virtues, but long experimentation has taught me that I most often prefer the French variety of scents.

In this thread I am going to discuss some fine scents which compose my winter scent wardrobe. Characteristically, I will start with a scent which is likely to be the most challenging scent I describe, simply because it's currently the scent about which I'm most passionate.

This is Annick Goutal's Encens Flamboyant. - This scent was first offered in 2007 and was composed by perfumers Camille Goutal and Isabelle Doyen. Fine scents are often compared to musical compositions with top, middle and base scent notes as the scent evolves during wear.

Encens Flamboyant roughly translates to flaming incense. It's intended to echo frankincense and fine fir resins added to a smoldering fire. And it does! The main notes I, and many others detect are smoke and pine. The smoke hits first and can be a bit harsh, perhaps almost medicinal until it quiets down when the smell of pine begins to become more prominent. As I said, it's challenging, but for me it becomes both warm, yet somewhat mysterious as the notes play hide and seek with each other. And despite this description, this is really a subtle scent which stays close to the skin despite being EDP strength. Those used to the strong, sweet scents which are more typical of drug/department store scents that hit you over the head shouldn't waste their time with it. But those who like incense and pine, and apply this scent sparingly and dispersed, may find themselves enwrapped in a subtle winter mystery.

View attachment 38610

My Winter scent is mothballs
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,896 Posts
Interesting topic @Flanderian. I always enjoy reading your posts.

The most I will do scent wise is an aftershave balm from Truefitt & Hill. This time of year Grafton and Trafalgar are nice. I like 1805 when the temperatures warm up. The scent of any of the balms dissipates quite quickly...and I'm fine with that.
 

· Read Only
Joined
·
2,318 Posts
When I joined AAAC, I was on a fragrance kick, hence my username.

Unfortunately, everyone and their dog now has a scent allergy. Not allowed at school or workplaces, gyms, etc.

I love all kind of scents, from spicy/acrid oud oil, to sickly sweet apple pie scents, to musky ones.

I started buying more and more strange niche scents, but designer fragrances are often more versatile IMO.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
27,866 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
Personally, I haven't worn cologne since trying some after Walt Frazier disclosed, in Rockin Steady - A Guide to Basketball and Cool, that he wore ?Aramis?, but my wife does enjoy the smell of a fire, and after watching that Katie Puckerik review I should probably revisit. Ha ha. That review was worth watching. I've subscribed.

Years ago, if memory serves, there were ads for scents containing pherones which were claimed to have desirable effects with the ladies. Those seemed promising.

Until Flanderian's post I had never considered scent as an element of dressing well that would need coordinating with what else is worn and the context for which the wearing is done. Very interesting, as usual.
Sniffen' can be addictive! :eek:

Katie knows her stuff, and is both entertaining and cute as a button!

If you like smoky try Replica "By The Fireplace" Perfume by Maison Margiela available at Sephora.
You'll smell like you been around a campfire for the weekend. I actually liked it and almost bought a bottle.
Thanks, I'll look for a sample!

Indeed! 60% of the time they worked every time.
1578004175942.png
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
27,866 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 · (Edited)
I shower and wash my hair with a bar of Irish Spring Deodorant Soap which leaves me "fresh and clean as a whistle" and smelling just that way. I try to insure any colognes or aftershaves that I apply complement that 'just out of the shower' smell. Geo F. Trumpers Essence of Lime cologne is effective in achieving that end. I also occasionally apply one of Geo F. Trumpers scents that leaves one smelling faintly like violets. Pretty prissy, huh? LOL. ;)
Geo. Trumper makes good stuff! Discretion is the heart of style, and I don't find anything prissy at all about violets. It's nonsense that floral notes can't be included to produce thoroughly masculine scents.

I have a wardrobe of scents, rather in the same way that I have a wardrobe of everything else - a sense of curiosity, a long life, and a hyperactive credit card.

My first husband also left behind a large collection of scents, some of which he acquired in a mania of purchases, only for him to abandon interest in them, and revert to his standby - Hermes Eau de l'Orange Vert, which he would buy, when he found it at a good price, in mass quantities.

I have been working through his older scents, wearing them on the weekends or as the weather permits (the heaviest scents - Penhaligon's LP9, and Patou for Men - get worn only when the temperatures go below freezing). He was also given, some 35+ years ago, a bottle of Bernard Lalande, which he never liked, and I always did, which I use only for special occasions (the last wearing was for the Frick Autumn Dinner).

For my own tastes, I use scents from three English-based perfumers - Trumpers (Skye), Floris (Elite in cooler months, Cefiro in warmer months) and Penhaligon's (Hamman Bouquet, which I'm wearing today; Eau Sans Pareil; Esprit de Roi; Racquets, occasionally, as it's been discontinued; and the aforementioned LP9, which, after it's gone, I will not replace).
You, Sir, have a very impressive collection of fine scents! But I would have been disappointed had you missed a further opportunity to express yourself.

Like, you, I've titled the thread winter scents because those I'm including those which work best in cold, or at least cooler weather, and would wear rather cloying in summer.

My Winter scent is mothballs
:D :D :D

Interesting topic @Flanderian. I always enjoy reading your posts.

The most I will do scent wise is an aftershave balm from Truefitt & Hill. This time of year Grafton and Trafalgar are nice. I like 1805 when the temperatures warm up. The scent of any of the balms dissipates quite quickly...and I'm fine with that.
Thank you! 👍

When I joined AAAC, I was on a fragrance kick, hence my username.

Unfortunately, everyone and their dog now has a scent allergy. Not allowed at school or workplaces, gyms, etc.

I love all kind of scents, from spicy/acrid oud oil, to sickly sweet apple pie scents, to musky ones.

I started buying more and more strange niche scents, but designer fragrances are often more versatile IMO.
I'd expect nothing less! 😉
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
27,866 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
Mind posting your collection Flanderian?
All in good time! ;)

Thank you for asking.

Though collection is rather elevated term for the small number of scents I currently wear. I like wearing scents, but don't really collect them. For many years I wore only one, and then found I enjoyed changing them with the seasons. But it's only the cooler season(s) which encourage olfactory prolixity.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
787 Posts
Every now and then I pass by a woman whose perfume smells so good that you want to follow her around like “a dog that begs for something sweet” (to quote Morrison). It would be nice to think there is an equivalent for men.

I wear Aqua di Parma in summer and Aqua di Parma Quercia in cold whether. No idea why.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,131 Posts
I have been and continue to be a scent aficionado. I cannot begin to estimate the thousands$$$ I've spent on my collection of fragrances, some regrettable. I try to chose wearing by season, mood and dress and that applies to my choice of soaps and shower gels. I have a hoard of long since discontinued fragrances, many of which are original formulas containing rare or banned ingredients. I doubt I will make any further expensive purchases as I have more than enough to last several lifetimes. I prefer fougeres,(sp), woods (ceder ), ambers and of course citrus especially in summer. I find many of the current modern fragrances off putting. I lavish upon my wife the same as I do myself,
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
27,866 Posts
Discussion Starter · #17 ·
Every now and then I pass by a woman whose perfume smells so good that you want to follow her around like "a dog that begs for something sweet" (to quote Morrison). It would be nice to think there is an equivalent for men.

I wear Aqua di Parma in summer and Aqua di Parma Quercia in cold whether. No idea why.
Superb scents, IMHO.

I have been and continue to be a scent aficionado. I cannot begin to estimate the thousands$$$ I've spent on my collection of fragrances, some regrettable. I try to chose wearing by season, mood and dress and that applies to my choice of soaps and shower gels. I have a hoard of long since discontinued fragrances, many of which are original formulas containing rare or banned ingredients. I doubt I will make any further expensive purchases as I have more than enough to last several lifetimes. I prefer fougeres,(sp), woods (ceder ), ambers and of course citrus especially in summer. I find many of the current modern fragrances off putting. I lavish upon my wife the same as I do myself,
It's easy to spend too much money on scent. Many/most particularly fine scents are not inexpensive. Fortunately, used sparingly as I believe they should, they often can last a long time. And I'm glad that I can be well pleased with a smaller number.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
27,866 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·
Mechant Loup by L'Artisan Parfumeur - Introduced in 1997 and created by perfumer Bertrand Duchaufour. If Encens Flamboyant is a crackling campfire in a snow hushed pine forest, Mechant Loup is a ramble in a very different wood, in a very different season. This wood is full of the sunshine and birdsong of ripe autumn or bursting spring.

Mechant Loup in French is wicked wolf. But he's nowhere to be found in this sunny wood, nor will any mistake you for him. The main scent accord of Mechant Loup is anise, hazelnut and honey. Why, you ask, would I want to smell like a strudel!? Because L'Artisan likes to mess with you! While the main scent notes may be something to eat, they don't smell anything like food, and the scent isn't particularly sweet at all. Rather you get very natural versions of these scent notes, rather than the confectionery versions. The overall impression is woodland, forest, the outdoors. And that's about as close as the wolf gets.

L'Artisan is famous (Infamous?) for the delicacy and discretion of many of their scents, and this is certainly the case with Mechant Loup. Both projection and longevity are gentlemanly. I include it as cool/cold weather scent only for the anise, which for me consigns it to this season.

Perfume Bottle Liquid Plant Cosmetics
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,131 Posts
Every now and then I pass by a woman whose perfume smells so good that you want to follow her around like "a dog that begs for something sweet" (to quote Morrison). It would be nice to think there is an equivalent for men.

I wear Aqua di Parma in summer and Aqua di Parma Quercia in cold whether. No idea why.
Funny you say that. More than once I ave been complimented on the fragrance I was wearing by both men and women while shopping. One women in fact followed me around the store while apologizing for doing so, said something about reminiscing about how it reminded her of time spent in Europe. My wife had a good chuckle over that when I told her about the experience.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,131 Posts
Mechant Loup by L'Artisan Parfumeur - Introduced in 1997 and created by perfumer Bertrand Duchaufour. If Encens Flamboyant is a crackling campfire in a snow hushed pine forest, Mechant Loup is a ramble in a very different wood, in a very different season. This wood is full of the sunshine and birdsong of ripe autumn or bursting spring.

Mechant Loup in French is wicked wolf. But he's nowhere to be found in this sunny wood, nor will any mistake you for him. The main scent accord of Mechant Loup is anise, hazelnut and honey. Why, you ask, would I want to smell like a strudel!? Because L'Artisan likes to mess with you! While the main scent notes may be something to eat, they don't smell anything like food, and the scent isn't particularly sweet at all. Rather you get very natural versions of these scent notes, rather than the confectionery versions. The overall impression is woodland, forest, the outdoors. And that's about as close as the wolf gets.

L'Artisan is famous (Infamous?) for the delicacy and discretion of many of their scents, and this is certainly the case with Mechant Loup. Both projection and longevity are gentlemanly. I include it as cool/cold weather scent only for the anise, which for me consigns it to this season.

View attachment 38622
Nice scent but not suited to me, Dzing is another one. I have eliminated all L'Artisan fragrances from my collection. Nothing wrong with them, just not suited to my body chemistry. I'm not fond of gourmand fragrances, or those that smell of burning rubber tires, ( Dzing ) and some of their amber fragrances are much too strong. Timbuktu, meh. Just my opinion. Fragrances combined with body chemistry are fickle devils, they will burn you or elevate you. Some will clear a room and some that will draw that room towards you. Don't let advertising hype fool you. Many fine fragrances and the houses that produced them have endured . Guerlain's Shalimar, the original Habit Rouge, still might be available on ebay. Others like Tiffany for men, gone. Jean Patou pour homme, eua de Patou pour homme, gone. I could go on. Thankfully Amouage still available, gold and Dia. Newcomers like Nicolai have some winners, New York and cedrat, they will probably remain for a long time. Creed have always had some time tested gems, green Irish tweed, bois de Portugal and more. A s with anything else, a matter of personal preference. Bottom line, you may like but, it might not like you.
 
1 - 20 of 59 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top