ASK ANDY ABOUT CLOTHES 

Back to HOME Page
               Info about The ENCYCLOPEDIA of Men's Clothes              
FORUMS

 The World's Most Popular Website  Devoted to Men's Clothing Advice!

 


Ask Andy
DEPARTMENTS


Men's Fashion Forum
Clothes Closet
What to Wear and When
Menswear Industry News
Lifestyle
Travelin' Man
Andy's Quiz Challenge
Tee Time
Favorite Men's Store

Encyclopedia
Newsletters
FAQs


Back to HOME Page

Your support of this site is appreciated and accomplished when you purchase from these merchants, specially chosen
for their high standards and quality products. 

AskAndy reader's 
most popular
merchants


 

Alexander S. Kabbaz
http://www.CustomShirt1.com

Why Bespoke Shirts

As I've watched over the years, there has been thread after thread on the Ask Andy FASHION FORUM comparing the virtues of many Ready-to-Wear brands, R-T-W Brands vs. Bespoke shirts, and at the top of the food chain, comparisons among the various bespoke makers.

This series deals with only the second thought, that of Ready-to-Wear in contrast to Bespoke. I shall neither comment on Arrow v. Borelli (except to say that the Arrow is probably a better value), nor shall I opine on whether Charvet out-gussets Turnbull or Paris is more beautiful than Geneva.

My sole goal here is to explain why bespoke shirts will serve you better than the pursuit of the ultimate R-T-W.

Future threads in this series will deal with fit, quality of construction, levels of craftsmanship, and choice of styling options such as cuffs, collars, yokes, pockets, front center treatments ... but that's for later. This thread will explain in very simple terms the primary and overarching advantage of Bespoke vs. Ready-to-Wear: Selection of the Fabric.

The average well-stocked specialty menswear retailer will have in current season stock somewhere in the neighborhood of 50-100 different R-T-W shirts, each in a variety of sizes ranging from 14-32 to 37-17.5. A large department store may as much as double that. Within that selection must be included button cuffs, French cuffs, self-collared shirts, white-collared shirts, as well as perhaps a few tabs and button-downs. Hence, for the person seeking a specific type of shirt, that 100 shirt selection gets divided down by at least a factor of four, leaving a universe of maybe 25 fabrics from which to choose.

It is different at a reputable bespoke maker:

One of the advantages is that you will be offered not only current season stock, but due to the long lag time in the Ready-to-Wear trade, you will even have the privilege of choosing from Next Season's offerings. New fabrics are offered at the same time to Bespoke as well as R-T-W makers. The major difference is that a bespoke maker can have a shirt made for you within days or weeks whereas even the fastest R-T-W production process requires a minimum of six months ... and usually longer.

Advantage One: Be the first on your block

It is different at a reputable bespoke maker:

Though specialty menswear and department stores will usually have an oxford and maybe a jacquard, the vast majority of their offerings will be broadcloths. Of these, the overwhelming number will be single ply 80's; the 'special selection' on the top shelf will consist of a few two ply 100's and perhaps one 'World's Finest' 2x2 120s or a Sea Island. Not so in the world of custom. Any good shirtmaker will stock oxfords, broadcloths, voiles, jacquards, meshes, basket-weaves, blends of linen & cotton, pure linen, silk and maybe even a cashmere-cotton or cashmere-silk. Most of those will, in turn, be offered in 80's singles, 100's singles, 80's 2x2, 100's 2x2, 120's 2x2, 140's 2x2, 160's 2x2, 180's 2x2, and the pinnacle of all, 200's 2x2. Heck, the bespoke maker has more variety just in types of fabric than a menswear store can carry in their entire selection of patterns!

Advantage Two: You order type of fabric which suits your purpose

It is different at a reputable bespoke maker:

The bespoke maker cannot survive by offering 100 fabric designs. In order to satisfy the variety of needs of a group of sophisticated shirt clients, the average custom house will stock a few more than that. This is where words fail. Enjoy:

 

 

 

[b]Advantage ... the Ultimate: You order type of fabric which suits your purpose ... from a selection of thousands.

 

The Fused versus Traditional Collar.

a] Style: A properly fused collar is always 'flat'. A traditional collar is, no matter how accomplished the ironer, always a bit 'wavy'. There are those who like to think that the 'wavy' appearance is more traditional. They are entirely correct. A cobblestone street is also more traditional than an asphalt one. Upon which would you rather drive for eight hours? In the arena of styling, therefore, neither fused or traditional methods are 'better'. Preference here is strictly in the eye of the wearer. In my case, I lean towards fused for my dress shirts and traditional for casual or sport shirts.

b] Construction: Without boring you with hours of technical details, the fused collar is much, much more difficult to properly construct than a traditional one. However, it is easier to improperly construct a fused collar than a traditional one. The reasons for these seeming contradictions are many; understanding can be accomplished only by in-person observation.
 
c] A poorly constructed traditional collar will always remain exactly as poorly constructed as it was in the first place.

d] A poorly constructed fused collar will get worse continuously throughout its life. A few of the major pitfalls include continuous shrinkage, debonding between the shell fabric and interlining resulting in bubbles in the shell fabric, and debonding of multiple inner layers of interlining resulting in non-removable ridges.

e] The majority of fused collars were, during the 1980's and 1990's, poorly constructed. Though the percentage of more appropriately fused collars seems to be on the increase, there is no way other than reputation to judge fusing quality prior to multiple launderings.

f] To the skilled maker, there are a myriad of additional styling options and wonderful construction features available only through the use of a fused collar.

g] A Footnote: Fusing other parts of the shirt is always questionable. The fused component of the collar (the 'leaf') does not touch the skin and is therefore not the part that gets a 'ring around the collar'. The 'ring' affects the non-fused collar band. This is important because soil removal from fused parts is more difficult. For this reason, fusing folding French cuffs is a terrible idea. Fusing is fine for button cuffs as the fused side does not come in contact with the skin. However, button cuffs are commonly used for casual or sport shirts which, in my opinion, are preferably made with the more wavy, loose, traditional methods.

The Fusing Process I have been asked to describe the fusing process. Fusing is a process involving the use of high temperature (approximately 155 degrees Centigrade) and high pressure (approximately 35 pounds per square inch) which causes the shell fabric (cotton shirting) to adhere to the interlining. The adhesion is provided by a polyamide adhesive. Polyamide adhesive is a type of plastic. In the actual process the cut collar shaped cloth, interlining, and its coating of adhesive are sandwiched together. They are then heated to the specified temperature. When the specified temperature is achieved, the high pressure is applied uniformly to the three part sandwich for a short period of time which varies from 12 to 18 seconds.

The pressure is then removed and the sandwich allowed to cool. The resulting collar exterior is now flat and somewhat "hard". It then returns to the normal shirtmaking processes, is made into a collar, and attached to the shirt as any traditional construction might dictate. The polyamide bond is permanent as long as it is not again heated above 150 degrees Centigrade. In the vast majority of commercial operations, this fusing process is accomplished in a fusing machine which contains a heat tunnel through which passes a conveyor belt. The sandwich is placed on the conveyor belt, proceeds through the heat tunnel, and is then run in-between two high pressure rollers. It then continues out the far side of the machine while cooling. The problem with this process is that plastic or a plastic bond, if in motion while cooling, becomes weak.

A conveyor belt, due to the nature of its operation, is not a flat path but instead a series of waves caused by the underlying rollers. Thus, when the collar is cooling as it moves out of the tunnel, it is not only in forward motion but also undergoing the bending motion provided by the wave characteristics of the belt's rollers. My determination (back in 1982 as previously detailed) was that I needed a machine which would keep the collar/polyamide/interlining sandwich stationery during the cooling process.

If you look carefully at the machine, you will see a large aluminum plate suspended from springs. This is the heat surface. The collar sandwich is inserted on a flat metal plate underneath the heat surface where it is then allowed to achieve the necessary temperature. At that time, the 12 ton hydraulic jack you see at the top forces the heat plate down onto the collar sandwich. After the required dwell time, the heating surface raises off of the now fused collar. The metal plate is then withdrawn and its contents allowed to rest motionless until they return to room temperature. Hence, the collar remains perfectly stationary on a stable surface while the bond is drying. This results in the strongest possible bond.

Theory is wonderful; product testing reality. Prior to releasing any of the fused collars to my clients, I tested the machine and the resulting products for a period of 18 months. I have one of the original collars I fused back in 1984 on a pink broadcloth shirt. It has been laundered more than 250 times, which is completely unprovable, and I keep it here for all who might be interested in seeing it. The collar began at exactly 16.5 inches in size and is now 16.25 inches in size.

More to come. Thanks for reading.

Sewing a Collar

I received the following question from a member who is hesitant to post:

Good afternoon Mr. Kabbaz,
I'm in need of your shirtmaking expertise in regards of collars points. I'm slowly learning how to sew my own shirts and was wondering what techniques do you use to achieve a perfect point when constructing a collar? I've come across several sewing books and websites and have tried several of the techniques, but I'm still not happy with my results.


This is an extremely difficult question to answer without showing ... but I'll give it a quick shot.

Step One: Sew the three pieces of the collar leaf (2 shell cloth and 1 interlining) together on the three sides which do not join to the collarband.

Step two: Trim all excess cloth and interlining away from the point areas leaving 1/16" of each remaining outside the stitch. Trim back from the point about 3/8".

Step Three: Using your fingernails after years of practice or an iron in the interim, crease and fold the seam allowance 180°. Press as flat as possible.

Step Four: This is the hard to write part. Place your thumb over the folded under seam allowance so that your thumbnail is right on the point and pushing into it on one of the short sides. Place your index finger in the same position, at the same corner, on the long side. Grasp the uppermost layer of the shell cloth and turn the shell cloth over the other two pieces (1 shell cloth, 1 interlining) in the same manner in which you would right an inside-out pillowcase. Do not, under any circumstances, release the pressure of your thumb and index finger on the seam allowance.

Step Five: With your free hand, begin to work a bone folder or other small pointed object down into the corner until you can feel it under the thumb and index finger. A ground-round small
screwdriver is fine if you haven't a bone folder. Once you feel the folder point has reached your thumbnail, you may release pressure.

Step Six: Using a gentle but firm circular motion, move the bone folder 'round and 'round in the corner, pushing to and fro until the point begins to take shape. You can pinch the point with your free fingernails or your teeth all of which, in combination with the folder, is meant to push the point out from the inside as much as possible (until all interior stitches are at the seam edge) without pushing the folder through the cloth and making a hole.

Step Seven: Repeat for the other point.

Step Eight: Using your free hand to guide the shaping, pull the undercloth sufficiently while ironing to cause the seam edge to be ever-so-slightly to the underside. Press flat.

Step Nine: Topstitch the three showing sides.

Step Ten: Run a staystitch along the non-showing side to keep the three layers taut while performing the next process, attaching the collar band.

It has been pointed out to me (thanks Luis) that I never said that all seam allowances on professional shirts are always 1/4".

OK, class dismissed for today.

Copyright © 2005 Alexander S. Kabbaz. All rights reserved.

http://www.CustomShirt1.com

Kabbaz-Kelly & Sons Fine Custom Clothiers
* Bespoke Shirts & Furnishings * Zimmerli Swiss Underwear *

 

_______________________________________________
Andy's
The Encyclopedia of Men's Clothes


Andy's Encyclopedia of Men's Clothes contains complete information on every article of men's clothing:

Forty-Nine chapters
on what to look for in quality features, tips on fit, fabric, styles, how to look your best, and garment history.  
PLUS there are chapters on fabrics, clothing care, foreign size conversions and grooming.

This Encyclopedia software on CD-Rom is in easy to use HTML format so that you can instantly access any section of the book.  
It's a reference for classic clothing  that you will use constantly and will be a benefit to you for a long, long time.
 



Treat yourself! 
It's also an appreciated gift for your Dad, Uncle, Son!



Now REVISED with more illustrations and updated information 

Library of Congress Copyright Office Registration TX 6-429-994

-- Only $24.95 !

MAILED FREE TO ANY PLACE IN THE WORLD!!

Just click on the PayPal "Buy Now" button above, and select the quantity you want to order.
There are
NO shipping, tax, or handling costs!  
The CD-Rom Encyclopedia is mailed free to any place in the world!

You can order using a credit card or electronic check payments through PayPal
PayPal is a secure and convenient payment method with built in protection against fraud.  PayPal is free to join and use.

  Sign up for PayPal and start accepting credit card payments instantly.

Or use Google Checkout

For more information CLICK HERE

If you would like to send a money order please contact me by e-mail.

Here is a recent testimonial about THE ENCYCLOPEDIA OF MEN'S CLOTHES:

"I received The Encyclopedia of Men's Clothes this afternoon, Andy, and it's terrifically useful! Thank you for explaining how to access the various disk components--your instructions helped me to quickly navigate the book.

I particularly like your logical, straightforward approach to each section. I mean to say, it really makes sense to explain why something matters, then how to care for it once you've chosen to incorporate the thing into your life, and then to include a history of the item, which focuses the reader's attention on its intrinsic value to a gentleman's kit.

Your book is more useful than Esquire's Encyclopedia of 20th-Century Men's Fashions, because the latter serves as a chronicle not a guide. The Encyclopedia of Men's Clothes provides a road map for fellows who wish to understand the choices they make, and who wish to make choices they understand. I am simply delighted with your book!"
-- J.de M. NM





For more Testimonials CLICK HERE

_______________________________________________

 

 

 

Back to Andy's Home Page


 

Click here to Ask Andy a question about men's clothes, fashion, history. . .

                                                                

Privacy Policy       About Andy

Copyright Ask Andy, Inc. 2001 -- 2008,     All Rights Reserved